Showing posts with label myth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label myth. Show all posts

Saturday, August 13, 2022

Comic Review: Iphigenia in Aulis: The Age of Bronze Edition

     This book features an original translation by playwright and author Edward Einhorn of the classic play by Euripedes, accompanied by high-quality black-and-white illustrations by Eric Shanower.

    The play itself is moving and certainly worth reading, although this is likely as true of other translations as of this particular one. The opening scenes are not quite as engaging as those later in the text: it's only once characters with different agendas begin engaging in dialog that the strengths of the author are truly evident. Iphigenia's final speech is particularly effective, but at the same time sounds what feel like at least a few false notes to the modern audience member, which are discussed briefly in an appendix.

    The illustrations are not so frequent as to overwhelm the text but complement it well by allowing one to read the facial expressions of the characters, much as one might in a dramatic rendering. (Of course, this wouldn't be the case in a traditional tragic performance of the play, in which the actors are masked. Somewhat ironically, the supplementary text reveals that this was the path the director took when staging this translation, meaning that viewers would have experienced the work very differently from readers despite the common text.)

    There are a few appendices with details of the stage production and thoughts on the text, as well as a glossary and family tree. These endnotes should probably be taken critically. In particular, the suggestion in the director's notes that 'the mob' is the true antagonist in the play seems dubious to me: I am half inclined to take the (always offstage) protests of the soldiers as merely an excuse for the male characters onstage to act according to their preexisting inclinations. Additionally, I believe that the glossing of "Centaurs" is simply mistaken: modern scholars have hypothesised that centaurs were inspired by horse-riding cultures who interacted with the early Greeks, but within Greek myth itself they were clearly human-horse hybrids.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

The Throne of Zeus

   This review was originally written with Demian's Gamebook Web Page in mind, but since they already have several reviews of the book, it seemed more effective to share my thoughts here instead.
   The Throne of Zeus is surprisingly effective at putting a great deal of mythological material in a small space. Most of the transitions between myths feel natural rather forced and you can see several play out nearly in their entirety. Glaring inaccuracies in the myths themselves are few, although some of the premises are more than a little suspicious. (There were physical thrones for each of the gods on Olympus? The gods have more interest in humanity on the summer solstice than during the rest of the year?) One disappointment was that the branches from one starting myth is much shorter than from the other.
   There are a few opportunities for the reader's character to become (semi-)divine which some may view as impious.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Foundations of Fantasy: The Odyssey

The Odyssey was written much as The Iliad was, in hexameter meant to be spoken aloud, though scholars commonly believe that it was written several decades later. It is the second-oldest book in western canon, after The Iliad... - From Foundations of Fantasy: The Odyssey The Iliad and The Odyssey (Barnes & Noble Leatherbound Classics)

The Aeneid by Virgil

Vergil's Aeneid: Books I - VI (PB)
The Aeneid is The Iliad’s lesser-known younger brother. It was written by the Roman poet Virgil between 29 and 19 BC, 800 years after Homer. The story begins directly after the events of the Trojan War, following Aeneas, son of Venus, through his escape from fallen Troy to his arrival in Lavinium... - From The Aeneid by Virgil